Brother's Pizza & Restaurant

Discover delicious Italian-inspired daily specials at Brother's Pizza & Restaurant in Cortland, OH. Savor homemade bread, tasty subs, white pizza, meatball pizza, stromboli, cheesesteak hoagies, chicken parm sandwiches, and baked ziti. Cash only. Visit us at 144 S High St or call +1 330-638-6555!

Welcome to Brother's Pizza & Restaurant

Taste the Difference.

Brother's Pizza & Restaurant
Brother's Pizza & Restaurant
Brother's Pizza & Restaurant
Brother's Pizza & Restaurant

Brother's Pizza & Restaurant stands as a beloved culinary gem in Cortland, Ohio. Located at 144 S High St, this cozy eatery is known for its mouthwatering subs and pizzas, drawing locals and visitors alike. Imagine sinking your teeth into a classic Italian sub or a slice of white pizza, each crafted with fresh ingredients and homemade bread. Cash-only transactions keep things simple, adding to the authentic diner experience.

Popular items include the meatball pizza, stromboli, and chicken parm sandwich, alongside baked ziti that warms the soul. Whether dining in or taking out, Brother's offers a taste of Italy right in the heart of Cortland, making it a must-visit for pizza enthusiasts.

Directions & Reservations

Plan Your Visit

Address

144 S High St, Cortland, OH 44410, United States

Phone

+1 330-638-6555

Social Media

About

The Culinary Story

Brother's Pizza & Restaurant
Brother's Pizza & Restaurant
Brother's Pizza & Restaurant
Brother's Pizza & Restaurant

Established as a community staple, Brother's Pizza & Restaurant has created a niche for itself in Cortland. The restaurant prides itself on its extensive menu that features diverse options, including Italian subs, hearty pizzas, and fresh salads. Its culinary specialties, such as the homemade bread, stand out, providing a unique touch that guests adore. As a cash-only restaurant, Brother's promotes a straightforward approach to dining, emphasizing the quality of food over complexities of payment. Many locals tune in for weekly specials and unique offerings, making it a gathering spot for families and friends alike.

With high traffic at dinner, particularly on Fridays, it’s clear that Brother's has a dedicated following. The ambiance reflects a blend of casual comfort and community spirit, enticing newcomers to dive into their rich dishes. Diners can choose to enjoy their meals indoors or grab some takeout for a night in. The restaurant also fosters a sense of belonging; regular customers often share stories and laughter while awaiting their meals. Nestled in the heart of Cortland, Brother’s Pizza & Restaurant remains accessible and welcoming to all who walk through its doors.

Work Hours

Availability and Service Times

  • Sunday4-9 PM
  • Monday11 AM-9 PM
  • Tuesday11 AM-9 PM
  • Wednesday11 AM-9 PM
  • Thursday11 AM-9 PM
  • Friday11 AM-9 PM
  • Saturday11 AM-9 PM

Brother's Pizza & Restaurant showcases the charm of casual dining with a focus on hearty meals at reasonable prices. The menu features an impressive selection, with an average dish priced at just $7.86. From classic subs like the cheesesteak hoagie to delicious salads, every item is made with care. Expect fresh ingredients, homemade sauces, and a warm atmosphere that makes for a friendly meal. The restaurant buzzes during peak hours, especially on Fridays when it operates at full capacity, suggesting a loyal customer base. For the best experience, consider visiting during the quieter hours, which allow for a relaxed dining environment. Plan ahead for the busiest days to secure a spot in this local favorite.

Brother's Pizza & Restaurant

Brother's Pizza & Restaurant, located along the busy S High St, boasts a warm, inviting exterior that reflects the charm of a local hangout. The casual vibe makes it easy to drop in for a quick lunch or a relaxed dinner. The building's straightforward design emphasizes functionality over flair, allowing the delicious food to take center stage. Though there's limited outdoor seating, guests often find solace inside, where the bustling atmosphere creates a friendly ambiance. The smell of fresh pizzas baking in the oven wafts through the air, setting the perfect backdrop for a satisfying meal with family and friends.

Guestbook & Reviews

Experience Through Their Eyes

Excellent Pizza and Stromboli's. They have other Italian entres as well but haven't tried them yet. The bread/crust is delicious! Perfectly cooked and flavorful. The ambiance here is also special. Feels like little Italy in NYC! Check it out

D
David B.

Amazing Italian and meatball subs at this place. Fresh bread and ingredients with so much taste! Skip the chains and go to this place for an amazing sandwich. Bring cash as they don't take debit cards. Try one of these subs, today!

K
Ken B.

Taste from my past! I grew up in Cortland, and moved away 35 years ago. When it comes to Submarine sandwiches I try to make it here a few times throughout the year because I love their homemade sub bread and the service is quick and pleasant. It's a great combination of delicious and nostalgic.

H
Holly S.

I was just at this wonderful Pizza restaurant because I was out in Cortland. I lucked out. THE BEST PIZZA I HAVE EVER HAD. Please take your time and go Ps we ate most of it in the car. It was too good to wait.

K
Kelly M.

NY style delicious and stromboli also. Side sauce for stromboli should be the same sauce on pizza, it tasted a little like Arby's sauce

S
Sizz007

Don't miss out. BEST in Waren, and locally owned!!

S
Shirley S.